‘Let us live our lives’: A call for justice from Masafer Yatta

March 18, 2022


Since this eyewitness story was published, the Israeli High Court of Justice have ruled to forcibly expel the residents of Masafer Yatta. Please see our urgent action.

‘Please don’t damage the hope of the people of Masafer Yatta and let us live our lives. We already have our homes here, our families and our animals and land: it is everything we need to live. There is great history, culture and tradition in Masafer Yatta and if the court rules in favour of a Firing Zone this will be destroyed. The beautiful environment and nature of Masafer Yatta will also be under threat if the area is used as a Firing Zone.’

Nidal Abu Younes, Jinba, Masafer Yatta

These are the words of local resident, Nidal, in the wake of the recent decision by the Israeli Supreme Court to suspend a final verdict on the future of Masafer Yatta. After a 20-year legal battle, the court decided on 15 March to once again delay a verdict on whether to forcibly evict around 1,300 Palestinians living in eight communities in the area. The land has been in their families for generations but life here has been precarious since Israel declared around 7,500 acres of Masafer Yatta a military training ground, ‘Firing Zone 918’.

Despite the Firing Zone only being designated in 1980, families that have lived and worked the land there since before the creation of the State of Israel have already been forced out of their homes once. The previous forcible displacement was carried out in 1999, when the Israeli military evicted the residents from their homes and into trucks with only what they could carry and no place to go.

With legal assistance, residents petitioned the Israeli High Court of Justice and managed to return to their homes in 2000. As no legal ruling has been made to date, the case has remained pending. The communities have been given interim injunctions to remain in their homes, however it is an extremely precarious existence.

Click for detail. Map showing Firing Zone 918 in yellow. Source: B’Tselem

‘While the power of interim injunctions since 2000 has prohibited Israel from expelling the residents, it has also put their lives on hold. They continue to live in their homes and work their land under constant threat of demolition, expulsion and dispossession. At the same time, Israel denies them any possibility of construction or development.’

Building permits are not granted in military Firing Zones, so any construction or development in these eight Palestinian communities is considered illegal under Israeli military law, which governs the area. To meet the needs of a growing population, many families build homes and infrastructure anyway and live with the risk that they will be demolished.

We recently met local resident Jabir in the ruins of his house in the village of Khallet Athaba, which has been demolished, not for the first time. We took in the sad views of other demolished homes, but also the beautiful views of the landscape of Masafer Yatta. He welcomed us with copious cups of ‘shay marameya’ (sage tea), laughter and stories. His family has owned land in the area for more than one hundred years.

The cosy houses here are perched on the mountainside and most have been demolished more than once. After each demolition, Jabir and his community members rebuild, reusing as much as they can from the rubble.

‘When they destroy our homes, we will rebuild them.’

Jabir, Khallet Athaba, Masafer Yatta

Jabir standing in the ruins of his demolished home in 2022

Members of Jabir’s family sitting on salvaged furniture after their living tent was confiscated in 2019

As we sat with him, drinking ‘shay’, Jabir also shared that there had been a recent settler attack. The Israeli soldiers present did nothing to prevent the violence and were heard saying ‘fight as you like…’. He also recounted another incident where two Palestinian farmers were shot in the arm and another in the leg by Israeli settlers. I wrote in an earlier eyewitness story that Palestinians seldom see justice for settler violence.

‘Contributing to these worsening conditions are Israeli military operations and trainings in the area, coupled with expanding settlements and acts of settler violence.’

Palestinian human rights organisation, Al Haq

The day after we visited Jabir, we received a call about another demolition in Khallet Athaba, this time of four rainwater collection cisterns. These cisterns are created using natural caves in rock and topping them with cement to direct the water to the cave and to cover the top. Many communities rely on these cisterns to provide water for both the people living in the community and their animals.

Neighbouring Israeli settlements and settler outposts benefit from water provided at a discounted rate from Israeli company, Mekorot, via piped infrastructure. The Israeli military who have full control over this area refuse to allow most Palestinian communities to connect to mains water. When their cisterns run dry, they are forced to import their water from Mekorot by truck with high transportation costs. All the trucks are reliant on a single local filling station.

In a recent article for +972 magazine about the latest court hearing, Basil Al Adraa of At-Tuwani, Masafer Yatta writes;

‘Our expulsion from Masafer Yatta has never ceased over the last two decades. Lacking the ability to expel everyone at once, like in 1999, the army has tried to slowly dispossess us. To immiserate us until we leave. Every year, I have watched as Israeli soldiers seal our wells, cut water lines, and destroy the roads that connect our villages.’

The single water filling station for the area of Masafer Yatta

Demolition convoy destroying water cisterns at Khallet Athaba

‘The High Court of Justice chooses to overlook the goal of Israel’s policy: forcible transfer of these residents.’

Israeli human rights organisation, B’Tselem

Numerous villagers from the eight communities petitioning against the Israeli military’s attempt to forcibly displace them attended the High Court of Justice for the latest hearing. The judge was reminded of a transcript document from a government meeting in 1981, presented at an earlier hearing. It showed then agriculture minister, Ariel Sharon suggesting they establish the military training zone in Masafer Yatta, in order to prevent the ‘expansion of the Arab villagers from the hills towards the desert’.

According to Israeli human rights organisation B’Tselem, ‘over the years, the Supreme Court has permitted nearly every kind of human rights violation that Israel has committed in the Occupied Territories.’ As the eight communities of Masafer Yatta face another court postponement and more uncertainty, they continue to rebuild from the rubble against all odds. As our chat comes to a close, Nidal calls for your solidarity and action:

‘I would like to say for all the world that because our case has been in the court for 22 years, I feel like this has become a political battle and there is no justice. We would like the High Court of Justice to act according to law and justice and morals, and not to forcibly displace eight of the villages in Masafer Yatta. We would like the international community to help us achieve our rights by exerting diplomatic pressure for change.’

Nidal Abu Younes, Jinba, Masafer Yatta


Since this eyewitness story was published, the Israeli High Court of Justice have ruled to forcibly expel the residents of Masafer Yatta. Please see our urgent action.

Take action!

  1. Use our email template for UK or Ireland to contact your elected representatives and call for immediate justice for the residents of Masafer Yatta.

  2. Watch this 3-minute video by Palestinian human rights organisation, Al Haq to learn more about the situation in Firing Zone 918.

  3. Learn more about demolitions and settlements in Palestine by reading our housing page.

What does international law say?

'Individual or mass forcible transfers, as well as deportations of protected persons from occupied territory to the territory of the Occupying Power or to that of any other country, occupied or not, are prohibited, regardless of their motive.'

Article 49, Fourth Geneva Convention, 1949

'Any destruction by the Occupying Power of real or personal property belonging individually or collectively to private persons, or to the State, or to other public authorities, or to social or cooperative organizations, is prohibited, except where such destruction is rendered absolutely necessary by military operations.'

Article 53, Fourth Geneva Convention, 1949

by EA Jessica   –    March 18, 2022

Share now